Rapid City was incorporated as a city in 1888 with an Act of Incorporation. From 1888 to 1910 and from 1957 to the present, the community has operated with an aldermanic form of government. Today Rapid City’s business is conducted by a mayor and a 10-person city council. Rapid City is divided into five wards, each of which elects two representatives to the city council to three-year terms. The mayor is elected at-large. Rapid City covers 55 square miles and is also known as the “Gateway to the Black Hills” and the “City of the Presidents”. Rapid City is second most populated city in South Dakota, with 74,048 people in 2016.
During its history, Rapid City has used three forms of government (returning to one later on). Descriptions of the forms of government are based on information from the National League of Cities. The four periods of government were:
Home Rule is the idea where local governments are able to do anything not prohibited by state law or the state constitution.
In South Dakota (and much of the USA), cities are run under Dillon's Rule. In brief, Dillon's Rule states that local governments only have the powers granted to them by the state. Conversely, a city run under Home Rule has all the powers that the state has not specifically restricted (for example, starting in 1997, Home Rule cities were prohibited from passing taxes that a non-Home Rule city could not). Chapter 6-12 of the Codified Laws of South Dakota covers the rules of establishing a Home Rule charter.
Home Rule was added to the South Dakota Constitution in 1962. In 1965, Rapid City voters rejected a Home Rule charter. Since then, ten cities have adopted charters. Mayor Keith Carlyle investigated the option of changing Rapid City to Home Rule in 1989, but it was never put to a vote.
In December 2019, the Mayor and City Council requested that a committee be formed to investigate the adoption of a Home Rule Charter. Mayor Allender appointed 18 members to the committee in May 2020. The members of the committee met bi-monthly for the next year to consider the option of a Home Rule Charter. On May 20, 2021, the committee presented their recommendation to the City Council. The committee recommended a charter that included a city manager and a seven-member council. The committee was met with criticism from citizens and council members, and no action was taken based on the committee’s recommendation.